Many years ago in my role as Head Physiotherapist for the Queensland Reds Rugby, we would do ‘The Plank Challenge’ as part of our pre-gym prehab routine.
Basically, the players would have to hold ‘the plank’ for as long as they could. Those who could hold for 3+ minutes were considered Spartans, between 2-3 minutes and they were considered worthy of Spartan status but needing some work, between 1-2 mins and they were peasants sent back to the remedial abdominal class, and below 1 min, well…they didn’t really last that long. And in all honesty, the ones with the best abs and no back pain are the ones who could generally hold the plank for 3mins+ without losing pelvic position. Losing pelvic position incidentally (more on this later) was the criteria for being booted out of the challenge.
So does mean that the plank is the best Abdominal Strength Exercise?
Well, it’s horses for courses really. If you weigh 120kg and do nothing but collect stamps and play chess all day then it will represent possibly the worst abdominal exercise you could embark on.
If you are an elite level Rugby player, then it may represent a higher level abdominal challenge.
What does the plank actually do? It is what Stuart McGill, the Canadian back-pain super-trainer refers to as a ‘super stiffness exercise’. It generates stiffness in all the abdominal wall muscles to create a rigid core between the rib cage and the pelvis. In doing so the spine is supported by muscle stiffness with minimal damaging compressive forces associated with sit ups and hanging leg raises.
The biomechanics of the exercise are quite obvious. Without some ‘stiffness’ in the muscles at the front of the body (as in abdominals) the body would sag under its own weight between the pivot and support points being the elbows and the feet. It thus requires a considerable degree of holding capacity in these muscles to generate the stiffness to prevent the spine arching into extension. But is that all it trains?
Many other muscles are also trained in this exercise and as a result, many other muscles can ‘cheat’ and compensate for weaker abdominals. If this occurs, then you are simply training those muscles with ability and neglecting the dysfunctional weal muscles. Before describing how other muscles work in this exercise (especially in cheating), let’s firstly describe the ‘perfect’ plank exercise.
In a perfect plank, the elbows are placed directly under the shoulders and the ankles are kept at 90 degrees bend. You can draw a straight line from the shoulders, through the hips, through the knees and through the ankles. This line will clearly slope downwards considering that the ankles are lower than the shoulders. But there should be any ‘breaks’ in this straight line. The most important pre-requisite however is that the pelvis is kept in ‘neutral tilt’. This means that the natural curve of the lumbar spine is maintained. It neither over-arches or as commonly seen, is not overly flat or even rounded (flexed or posterior tilt of the pelvis).
Cheat Number 1: Push the wrists into the ground and really dig your toes in and push with your calves. This creates an artificial ‘stiffness’ scenario. The triceps contract to try and extend the elbow, in doing so the body is pushed towards the feet. At the same time the calves contract to plantarflex the ankles, or to put it another way, push the body away from the feet. The 2 forces meet in the middle and les work is needed by the abdominals as the body has already artificially compressed itself. Solution. Do this on a timber floor with a tea towel under the elbows and under the feet. If you push too much with the arms or feet, they will slide due to that force.
Cheat Number 2: Resting the head on top of the hands whilst pushing with the feet. This does the same as above however now the head forms a block to movement. Push with the feet (as in calves), the body wants to move upwards but the head stops the movement. Result. Again artificial compression is generated. Solution. Head must be in line with the shoulders.
Cheat Number 3: Spine sagging and associated anterior pelvic tilting. This happens as the abdominals fatigue. You will see it in someone because their butt starts to stick out more and the arch becomes exaggerated in the spine. The reason this happens is that the hip flexors and the abdominals are trying to find a new physiological length-tension advantage. The anterior hip flexors will force the pelvis to anterior tilt and as a result the abdominals become slightly stretched, a more favourable position to continue to produce holding force. What can also happen is that the psoas major muscle will also start to kick in to support the spine from the front. What you will feel is a low back ache as the facet joints are compressed under the load of muscle contraction whilst locked into spine extension. Solution. Don’t lose neutral spine or neutral pelvis.
Cheat Number 4: Knees bend. Again as fatigue sets in, the body will look for ways to cheat. We ere born to cheat so the body will look for the most economical way to maintain a task with minimal effort. By allowing the knees to bend, the long rectus femoris muscle uses its physiological length-tension advantage. Because it also crosses the front of the hip, it is another muscle which is used to help ‘hold’ the hip in neutral so it does not sag into extension.
So therefore, what are the other muscles that can be trained in a ‘plank’ exercise. The list includes but is not limited to; triceps, anterior deltoid, clavicular head of pec, serratus anterior, TFL, rectus femoris, anterior adductors, soleus and gastrocnemius.
If performed incorrectly, then the ‘plank’ may possibly recruit as many muscles as the deadlift.
The only difference is that the deadlift is a good rehab exercise whereas a poorly performed plank is not a good rehab exercise.